How do you love me? let me count the ways (1.1.14-17) #BurningBarge #SlowShakespeare

CLEOPATRA   [to Antony] If it be love indeed, tell me how much.

ANTONY         There’s beggary in the love that can be reckoned.

CLEOPATRA   I’ll set a bourn how far to be beloved.

ANTONY         Then must thou needs find out new heaven, new earth. (1.1.14-17)

 

Despite the train, the women, the eunuchs, and the two censorious Roman soldiers, these two are completely wrapped up in each other (although not averse to an audience), mid flirty quarrel, and presumably one they’ve had many times before. Antony’s apparently been protesting that he loves Cleopatra: so, tell me, she says, if it be love indeed, tell me how much. I want to hear you say it, I want to be told again and again—but Antony picks up on tell as count and says that’s impossible; it’d diminish his love, their love to put a number on it; there’s beggary in the love that can be reckoned, he says, it’d impoverish it. We’re above that, we’re magnificent, we don’t need how much, numbers and words! That’s my call, though, she says: I’ll set the limit, define the terms if I want, tell you exactly how much you love me. I’ll set a bourn how far to be beloved, bourn as boundary. (Love as geographical, space and territory; the borders of a country to be defined by love alone. A grown-up development of Juliet’s ecstatic, innocent claim that her ‘bounty is as boundless as the sea’…) And Antony picks it up again, as they dance around each other in this great erotic sparring bout: if that’s the case, if you’re going to try to put a limit on my love, on our love, then must thou needs find out new heaven, new earth. You’ll have to redefine the world itself to set a limit on how much I love you, he says, you’ll have to go beyond its limits—and in saying so, he’s borrowing the language of Revelation 21, when the vision of the new heaven and the new earth marks the end of time and the end of the world. BIG LOVE, not just to the moon and back (these are not Donne’s ‘dull sublunary lovers’, far from it). Their world is a lovers’ world, entire and of itself, and nothing else matters. To infinity and beyond! So there.

 

View 2 comments on “How do you love me? let me count the ways (1.1.14-17) #BurningBarge #SlowShakespeare

  1. I came across the #SlowShakespeare blog through Google serendipity. What an absolutely marvellous resource! The blog seems like an act of idolatrous, intense and very time consuming devotion, or is it going too far to say it’s an act of love. Perhaps it’s designed to make us fall in love or fall in love again with Shakespeare’s “conspicuous genius.” Anyway, I’d like to express my gratitude.

    A couple of questions. Do you plan to extend the blog to cover more (all) of Shakespeare’s plays? Would the blog be more accessible / findable with its own non-Cambridge site? Could I also ask if there’s a critic/s on Shakespeare who you find particularly astute and insightful and would therefore recommend?

    1. Hooray for Google serendipity! I’m glad you’ve enjoyed it so far… It’s an act of self-indulgence, really, although it’s become very important to me to write every day. I started the R&J one because I was writing the introduction to the third edition of the New Cambridge edition of the play and it got my head (and heart) into it – and then I kept going because I enjoyed it, and particularly valued the interaction with teachers and general readers. Tempest and Richard II seemed appropriate in lockdowns, at least some of the time, although I chose the plays via Twitter polls… And then Macbeth (again via a Twitter poll) was good because it’s so often taught in schools. No plans to do all of the plays, no! I will do 2 Gents at some point, possibly next, because I’m editing that for Arden. I’m not hugely worried about making it more findable – lots of people find it via twitter, I think? and I don’t really have the nous to set up on my own, I’m reliant on the help of a kind Faculty computer officer. And as regards criticism – well, how long’s a piece of string? there’s so much out there, and I think it varies a lot, play by play and in terms of what you’re looking for… sorry! but thanks so much for commenting, and I hope you continue to enjoy reading. There’s a a LONG way to go in the gloriousness that’s A&C yet…

Leave a Reply to Hester Lees-Jeffries Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *